Local News: Record heat helps push Southeast Missouri over ozone threshold (07/22/12)

Home Return to classic website

Record heat helps push Southeast Missouri over ozone threshold

Sunday, July 22, 2012

Southeast Missouri isn't alone when it comes to recent ozone standard violations.

EPA representative Lachala Kemp told the Southeast Missouri Air Quality Committee on Friday that ozone exceedances are occurring this summer all over the country due to record temperatures.

Heat and sunlight are key ingredients in the formation of ozone.

"There have been some tremendous ozone readings, not just here, but all across the country," she said. "That high pressure is just sitting on top of the Midwest. We are taking that into consideration."

This summer, a monitor at Farrar, Mo., in rural Perry County has had nine exceedances. The only monitors with none are the West Alton monitor near St. Charles and the Maryland Heights monitor in St. Louis.

So far this summer, the four highest ozone measurements at the Farrar monitor in Perry County have been well above the standard of 75 parts per billion, coming in at 89, 85, 84 and 82.

"I'm in damage control mode right now," said David Grimes, deputy director of the Southeast Missouri Regional Planning and Economic Development Commission in Perryville, Mo., who coordinates the task force. "I don't see how we can miss a nonattainment designation."

Counties that fail to meet ozone standards are considered "nonattainment zones" and businesses there face restrictions on their emission of pollutants that contribute to the formation of ozone, such as nitrogen oxide and volatile organic compounds.

This summer's exceedances raise the area's Design Value, the measurement used by EPA to determine compliance, above the standard to 77 parts per billion.

The Design Value is a three-year rolling average of the fourth-highest readings from each year on the monitor.

While the EPA has the discretion to take action in response to the recent exceedances, typically the agency has not done that, Kemp said. The EPA is expected to release new ozone standards and designations for nonattainment areas in 2013.

To try to reduce ozone levels, the planning commission recently applied for and was accepted into the EPA's Ozone Advance program. Ozone Advance is a voluntary effort between the EPA and local governments to encourage emission reductions in areas that meet current standards to help the areas keep ground-level ozone in check.

While the group developed a Clean Air Action Plan last year, the air quality committee drafted a voluntary Clean Air Action Plan in 2010, it's yet to be implemented due to a lack of funding.

Kemp encouraged the group to review the plan and see where it could be strengthened. It included a "Stop at the Click," a program to encourage people not to overfill their vehicle's gasoline tanks after the automatic cutoff on the fuel nozzle has stopped the flow of gas; implementing "Clean Air Zones" where cars are prohibited to run idle; and steps local governments can take to improve air quality such as choosing low-emission and fuel-efficient vehicles; providing recycling facilities; and restricting open burning of waste.

Participating in the Ozone Advance program doesn't shield an area from being designated nonattainment if a violation of the ozone standard occurs, Kemp said.

"It looks like you guys may have one [violation] for 2010-2012, but data has not been quality assured and data has not been certified," Kemp said.

When the EPA determines nonattainment designations, it looks both at air quality data and planning and control efforts implemented by the community, she said.

The ozone season typically runs from April through October. If the county has additional ozone exceedances, its design value will not increase any more so long as there are no new ozone readings higher than 82 parts per billion. If readings occur above that level, it will push the monitor's average higher.

Grimes and others on the committee say air models show that on days when readings are high, the air is coming from other cities with many more sources of ozone ingredients, such as Chicago and the Ohio River Valley.

"We are the victims. We are not the originators of any of this pollution," said Kathleen Waltz, congressional outreach coordinator for U.S. Rep. Russ Carnahan's office.

Instead of going on the defensive, as Grimes suggested, Martin Toma, city administrator in Ste. Genevieve, Mo., suggested a more offensive approach.

"If we did everything right and stopped producing anything that contributed to ozone, how much difference would it make?" Toma said. "Can we work with the EPA to show that we are getting dumped on?"

Kemp agreed that there are many sources of ozone all across the country but said the only thing local communities with monitors in violation can control is what is in their local areas.

The ozone monitor in Ste. Genevieve County has also shown exceedances this summer, with its four highest readings coming in at 83, 83, 76 and 75. Its Design Value is at 72 parts per billion, still under the standard of 75.

The Air Quality Committee will meet again Oct. 19.

mmiller@semissourian.com

388-3646

Pertinent address:

Farrar, MO


Fact Check

See inaccurate information in this story?

View comments

The EPA is the first agency that should go bye bye.
— Posted by foreman, 07/21/12 at 1:12 PM
"The EPA is the first agency that should go bye bye."

Ah, so without any EPA (or other Federal agency performing the same role the EPA does) how would the Perryville area prevent pollutants from being dumped on them from sources in Chicago or the Ohio River Valley?

Statistically for every 10 pbp of extra ozone the citizens of Perryville have an approximately 4% additional chance of dying from respiratory diseases. So they are having a harm done to them, but in a states rights or libertarian scenario how can you do anything about that harm when largest contributors to that harm are hundreds of miles away in other states & other cities? Not to mention the harm is rather indirect and diffuse so their is no single big bad polluter to sue. If a Perry County child has a serious asthma attack and dies, and such a high ground level ozone level roughly increased the odds for such deaths by ~16% how do we hold hundreds of assorted factories and a few millions Chicago area commuters accountable for their tiny fractional contributions to that death?

The EPA does have plenty of bad regulations, and unfortunately industry plays a bigger role in setting numbers(many times to make life rough for smaller competitors) than hard medical research. Like most agencies it could use plenty of reform. However at least in the case of airborne & waterborne pollutants that can cause harms hundreds or even thousands of miles away from their sources you have to have an agency with jurisdiction that stretches as far as rivers flow & predominant winds blow to at least attempt to hold pollutants down and occasionally hold polluters accountable for excessive harm done unto others.

— Posted by Nil, 07/22/12 at 2:26 AM
I have Training & Education Video online so the factory and work and we can have clean air training in scrubber Operations have 940 classes www.isoclasses.com I can Help
— Posted by falcon2412, 07/22/12 at 7:53 AM
Suggest one of the first things to do if all are in agreement that the exceedances aren't entirely due to activity in the area, is to gain agreement on just where it's coming from.

"The Farrar monitor, southeast of St. Louis, showed no exceedance day trajectories directly from the St. Louis area, but a small sample of the lower limit exceedance days showed transport from a northwestern quadrant. The majority originated from southern to eastern directions, suggesting areas from Southern Illinois toward Memphis are important transport corridors 24 hours before the Farrar monitor exceedances." from http://www.dnr.mo.gov/env/apcp/ozone/met...

— Posted by fxpwt, 07/22/12 at 10:40 AM
I personally think it's rediculous when our own politicians choose business over the welfare of the citizens that live in these areas. There is more allergies, sinus problems and asthma in our

county because of the pollution. Air pollution also leads to death for elderly and those with cronic health issues. But that seems to be ok as long as we are making a buck. Who cares about the youth growing up let them be sick, instead of let them eat cake seems to be the political cry these days. We are just the citizens who care about their welfare, as long as corporations have plenty of corporate welfare we will never see justice. This welfare comes in the form of not paying local or state taxes for decades, government subsides and giving campaign contributions on both sides of the fence. It's the almighty dollar being chosen over the health of millions, not just here but across the country.

It's a sad comment that money talks while people are actually dying from the pollution these corporations put out. Holcim, Lime Kilm, quarries,

Falcom Foam and the obessive amount of semi's through our area from hwy 55, 51, 61 just rediculous amounts of pollution this adds to the atmosphere, etc., just to name a few of the local offenders. Not to mention route 3 and route 150 in Illinois it's non stop CO2's, SO2's, and NO2's. The culprits (meaning politicians) are being paid off and/or the offenders polluting always point there fingers at the EPA. The EPA is there for the publics well being and tries to protect the citizens and uphold the laws anyone with real moral character and values would see that. Maybe when they lose some one because of the

pollution maybe they will get it through their heads then. We can have jobs that don't pollute accessively like these do.

— Posted by newlg, 07/22/12 at 3:43 PM

Post comment

Posting a comment requires free registration. If you already have an account on seMissourian.com or semoball.com, enter your username and password below. Otherwise, click here to register.

Username:

Password:  (Forgot your password?)

Your comments:
Please be respectful of others and try to stay on topic.

Map of pertinent addresses

Related links